They Shall Not Grow Old

Okay, I admit it: I love documentaries.  So when I saw the coming attraction for They Shall Not Grow Old, I was immediately intrigued.  That was at least a month ago.  Well, I finally got around to seeing this new film from director Peter Jackson (Lord of the Rings, etc.) and am I ever glad I did.  This is a remarkable documentary.  Not only does it address the horrors of World War I (“the war to end all wars”—which it didn’t!), it does so in a totally unique way for an event that occurred one hundred years ago.

Ken Burns has done wonderful work with old footage and stills in recreating his award winning documentaries about the Civil War, the West, and baseball, but most of the images are either static, or compromised in some fashion.  Not so with Mr. Jackson’s work.  If you’ve ever seen film footage of the late 1900s or early 20th Century, you, no doubt, recall the erratic, jumpy images that marched across the screen in a kind of syncopation.  The movements are so stiff and out of time that they are laughable.  They Shall Not Grow Old manages to eliminate all the negatives generally associated with old moving pictures.

What struck me most about the film, which focuses entirely on the United Kingdom’s participation in the war, is the age of the participants.  Most are in their very early 20s, but a goodly number are teenagers.  Their stories are narrated by the recorded voices of actual veterans of the First World War, which ads a good deal of authenticity.  Also, there is no score.  Their are a few musical overtones: a chord here, a dissonant note there, but no actual score.  One thing should be noted: there is a great deal of gore shown, not the make believe stuff we see in the everyday shoot ‘em up, but true blood and guts.  After a while, because of the large amount shown, there is a tendency to look past it as if it doesn’t exist.  But exist it did.

The beginning of the film has director Jackson introducing it with some very meaningful insights as to why he chose to make the film.  After the credits roll, viewers are invited to hang around for about thirty minutes, while Jackson shows us exactly how he and his team managed to make the footage look so good, or, more to the point, almost current in its appearance.  Overall, this is one of the most amazing and touching documentaries ever made.  I urge you go and see it while it is still on the big screen.  I dare you to watch it without shedding a tear.

If you enjoyed this post, please share it with a friend, or reblog it on your own website.  If you’d like to follow my blog, just click on the “follow” button at the bottom righthand corner of the page.  You’ll be asked to enter your email address, and you’ll receive an email confirmation in return.  I only post once per week, and I never, ever share email addresses.
To learn more about me and my writing, visit my website at: or my author page on  If you’ve not read one of my Matt Davis mysteries, I hope you’ll give one a try.  Start with As the Twig is Bent; it’s the first in the series.  All five Matt Davis mysteries are now available in pocketbook editions.

About AuthorJoePerroneJr

I am a former professional fly-fishing guide, and I write the Matt Davis Mystery Series, which presently consists of five books: As the Twig is Bent, Opening Day, Twice Bitten, Broken Promises and Deadly Ransom. The series is set in the real town of Roscoe, NY, in the Catskill Mountains, where I guided for ten years. I love fly fishing, movies, cooking (and eating), and music. To learn more about me and my writing, please visit my website at:
This entry was posted in The movies and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to They Shall Not Grow Old

  1. War then meant everyone was involved; even those who stayed home had duty to do. Casualties were beyond comprehension. And yet the world learned nothing and had a repeat performance just years later in WWII. My first actual memory of my dad was watching him put on his uniform and march off down Richwood Ave until he disappeared around the corner. He came back but so many did not.

    Liked by 1 person

    • You must have been a real little feller . . . I’m glad he came back. My dad had flat feet, which disqualified him from serving. But, he petitioned President Roosevelt, and ended up a clerk typist.


  2. allenrizzi says:

    Little known fact: Over 8 million horses were killed in WW I.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Want to see this! Thanks for the review, Joe.


  4. Over 1,000,000 British men lost their lives in WWI. There’s one scene that shows a half dozen or so men, and every one of them was killed less than an hour after the footage was shot. I am really glad I saw the film. If nothing else, it gave me an opportunity to pay my respect to those brave young men.


  5. delphini510 says:

    To see this piece of film, seeing the young boys and men walking away with a smile.
    Later seeing so many dead and broken. It is heartbreaking.


    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.